Thursday, June 26, 2025

 


Opinion

India should change the nil taxation slab for salaried employees from 12 to 25 lakh per annum.

This should be the start of taxation reform. Salary reporting should be done by the firm they work for with no requirement for filing a return.

This calculation is nothing new – we have seen versions before.

On a 25 lakh per annum salary in Goa

20% is deducted for taxes as a rough measure or 5 lakhs approx.

40% needs to be allocated for EMI on home loan or 10 lakhs

10% is an approx. percentage of your car loan EMI or 2.5 lakhs

20% is left with you for your monthly expenses – school fees, groceries, any discretionary spending, medical expenses, clothes, school books, petrol etc. – That’s a total of Rs.40,000 a month. There is plenty not included.

Now this is on 25 lakhs. While 25 lakhs p.a. is a good salary in Goa, for the rest of the Indian middle class this might be struggle city.

Now what I am suggesting should not be looked at as a tax saving for the middle class rather than as a boost to the economy.

India is not a great saving nation – we do save but its not huge. We spend or rather are forced to spend. So, what will this abolishing do?

The fishmonger will have more sales, as will the bar owner, or the textile shop owner or the TV shops, or the car dealerships, the utensil shop …you name it everyone will benefit. So does the government – there is GST and other taxes on these sales anyway.

Above 25 lakhs have a flat 5% tax again deducted at source. No deductions, no caveats. You get a salary over 25 lakhs pay 5% tax, no slabs, no income tax filing. Simple.

And revise this upward every year. The economy needs the middle class to spend money for it to survive.

What does this do to the thousands of Income Tax employees. Use them to go after all those big corporations not paying taxes. Not only are they bigger fish to fry but the return is much more than a salaried person.

Out of the 86 million who paid tax last year, 44 million filed reports for earnings between 250,000 and 500,000.

Now this solution may not be applicable everywhere – but in India? Where less than 7% of the population filed taxes? And most of them were filing taxes for low earnings?

Perhaps it is time the 60,000 employees of the Income Tax Department were used to target bigger fish.

And for the middle class to have more disposable income

The economy needs it.

 

 

 

 

 

Thursday, June 19, 2025

Hindi is the "National" Language

 This was written in 2022 - 3 years ago


Since when did Hindi become the national language?


As I am adjusting to life in my current abode, I’m dealing with a variety of providers – Amazon, Airtel, Hero Honda; bought insurance and bought a car and a motorcycle - they almost exclusively speak in Hindi. 


There is no ascertaining if I would like to speak in another language – they launch straight into it.


I live in Goa, in the south west of India, where Konkani and Marathi are the official languages and English is used for everyday business communication.


I picked up my phone connections in Kerala, in the south where Malayalam and English are spoken. But Airtel always speaks to me in Hindi till I ask for an English speaker.


I have not brought a single product in Delhi, Haryana, UP or the other states where Hindi is commonly spoken.


For my generation, Goa has had limited exposure to Hindi as a common language.  The army barracks in Goa were the exposure to most Goans north of the Zuari river. And despite hilarious encounters – a friend once dropping off a female colleague at the cantonment informed the guards at the gates – “Mai Colonel Khurana ka beti ko chhodne aya hou”  - roughly translated he was there to have sexual intercourse with said person instead of saying he was dropping her off – Hindi was never mainstream for us.


Don’t get me wrong, I am fluent in Hindi and after English it is the language I am conversant in. A combination of living in central govt. housing and being exposed to the spoken language and having Hindi grammar drilled into me at school for 10 years ensured that. 


But Hindi is not the national language of India. It is an official language of India. 


And Konkani and Marathi are the official languages of Goa. And Malayalam is the official language of Kerala. 


Since when did Amazon, Airtel, Hero Honda etc. decide that Hindi is the language they will use to speak to their consumers? How about speaking to me in Konkani – Ok my Konkani has miles to go before it gets better – but I live in Goa. Or hey Airtel, how about speaking to me in Malayam – I bought my connections in Kerala after all?


But no Hindi it is. I refuse to converse in Hindi and ask for an English speaker. 


I have asked the consultant on the phone if they speak English or any other language that does not belong to the north of India and the answer is no. 


The call centres are in or around Gurgaon or Delhi and draw a lot of Hindi speakers to these jobs. But as we depend increasingly on online shopping and having to talk to customer service agents on the phone isn’t it time that companies realised that India is not a homogenous whole that speaks Hindi?


We are well aware of the political affiliation of major corporations – Bharati Airtel is one of the largest donors to the political party ruling India which has an avowed affinity for Hindi.


Call me a conspiracy theorist but if anything, 30 years of following politics has taught me is that there is usually more to it than appears on the surface.


Donations, admittedly huge donations are one thing, but corporations establishing call centres, headquarters, offices, service HQ’s in a party’s traditional vote bank areas provide employment. Employment to thousands of party supporters - mainly young people. 


And when a call centre does not require you to know English but requires Hindi you know who the jobs are geared to. 


Don’t get me wrong – elections are won and lost in the Hindi heartland and any political party will not be able to form government without these states. 


In the meantime, I refuse to budge. I will speak in English, Konkani or Malayalam but not in Hindi to somebody who call me on my phone. It is my custom that is paying for these salaries and I demand that you speak to me in a language that I am comfortable with – not a language you choose to impose on me.

Central (Jail) Library

He leans his chair back on two legs

Rests its back against the wall

Casually picks his nose

Flicks whatever he retrieved 

From that capacious nostril, and asks

Are you a member


I nod and he indifferently waves me through 

Least concerned about my veracity or intentions 

His role as security guard fulfilled 


The clerk at the counter barely lifts her head

Assesses me as no threat 

To her employment or sleep 

She cushions her head on a pillow 

At least the bolster has purpose

And resumes her daily slumber 


I wander through the dusty maze

Running my fingers on the tops of the stack 

Books bound in hardcover, titles typed on spines 

A remnant of some zealous librarian’s craft


The cobwebs form a canopy over the racks

Generations layered onto  generations 

Silverfish and book lice abound

A perennial food supply for arachnids 


I wonder at how many first editions must inhabit these musty corners 

Quietly disintegrating into pyramids of dust 

While avid collectors scour alleys and crannies 

Hoping to possess an elusive author 

To be the star of their collection 


I spot an old favourite of mine

The Count of Montecristo and 

Like its namesake in the Chateau d’If 

This book is a prisoner of the Central Library 


I flick to the back to see 

When this book was last in the sun

The checkout card sadly said 1981


As I leave this cavernous tomb

I look back and take it all 

Books as far as eye can see

Like terracotta warriors waiting for the call

Holy Shit !

What do you think of this vase asks my wife

Meh! I say and she buys it anyway

Woman, why do you involve me (John 2:4)


Standing in Delfinos with my grocery list

Confused what she means by Milky Mist

Calling her phone hoping she picks 

Answer me quickly, for I am in trouble (Psalms 69:17)


Searching frantically for my glasses case

I thought I left it in the bookcase 

And with a sigh she says

Do you have eyes but fail to see (Mark 8:18)


She says she needs new clothes

We need to go shopping 

And I make a face,

It’s something I loathe

Oh well she mumbles

If you go with me you will only be a burden  (2 Samuel 15:33)


As we prepare to head out for the evening 

The usual accusatory question arises

What are you wearing 

I open my wardrobe 

And prepare to disrobe

And then she says

I hate all these (Zechariah 8:17)


I consoled my gay religious friend 

Conflicted  about who he is 

Said  the Bible is in your court

He who sleeps with another man should be stoned (Leviticus 20: 13 )

Make sure you smoke a joint before 


Fear not for all that ails you 

The Bible is there to hold you 

Remember when you are in a black hole 

The Holy Book has many a loophole

Send Noods

 She chose a career in politics,

Brick by brick, she laid the fix.

Master of staying in the back,

Guiding others who’d gone off track.

A smile here, a handshake there,

Shielding her boss from public glare.

Then in one swift, cruel headline swoop—

She became the media’s scoop.

Wiped away like yesterday’s eyeliner,

By a husband shouting, “Here’s my Weiner!”


He spent the longest time just waiting,

While mummy dearest kept dictating.

He longed to carve himself a name,

But was reduced to rash and shame.

His dream? His Camilla near,

In a villa, sipping wine and cheer.

He wasn’t a sexter—but by text?

He left the nation quite perplexed.

They thought he rambled on  about beeswax 

When all he craved

Was to be reborn as her Tampax.


And while we scoff at all these men

And think the worst is in the pen

The prudes who preach and moralize

Are sending “Send Nudes” in disguise

We are like this wonly

 We deserve bad roads

We deserve the flooding

We deserve bad hospitals

We deserve bad ambulances 

We deserve bad paramedics 

We deserve bad electricity 

We deserve bad water 

We deserve bad schools

We deserve corruption 

We deserve high indirect taxes

We deserve high income taxes

We deserve apathetic bureaucracy 

We deserve nepotism 

We deserve indifferent governments

We deserve cronyism 

We deserve the taxi mafia

We deserve bad public transport 

We deserve low wages

We deserve a bad judicial system 

We deserve a lower life expectancy 

We deserve a higher infant mortality rate 

We deserve domestic violence

We deserve bad insurance 

We deserve poor press freedom

We deserve bad quality products

We deserve politicians who jump parties 

We deserve everything that’s shit in our lives 


Because we are Indian and ‘we are like this wonly’

Monday, May 19, 2025

My pet dog

 My black dog looks at me

Deciding … 

Is he going to walk so far ahead of me

That passing him seems an impossibility 

Or is he going to be behind me

Keeping me in his sight 

To dash past me suddenly 

Or is he best of all going to walk beside me

Allowing me to still him with a hand

A leash loosely held but in control 

Feeding treats, morsels to keep him in control.


He follows me home quietly 

Knowing what follows

And as night falls and I climb under the covers

He looks at me 

Deciding …

Is he going to climb up and sit on my chest all night

Or sleep beside me quiescent but ever present 


He never lets me out of his sight

My ever present shadow

With every conversation 

With every interaction 

Is he going to pounce on me and 

Shake me like a rag doll

Take a bite out of me

Crippling me leaving me in pain

Is he going rear his head at others 

Terrifying them with his bared fangs


From the crack of dawn to the cloak of midnight 

He’s there with me 

Deciding …